Smriti Irani (left) and Mayawati
Ancient Hindu philosophy depicts the balance of the universe as
dependent on the perfect harmony of the male and female principle. The
rise of 38-year-old Union HRD Minister Smriti Zubin Irani symbolises the
growing shakti of the female voice in Indian politics. Irrespective of
the aggression and strategic nuances of the content of her speeches
within and outside Parliament, Irani has set new paradigm of the
fiercely uncompromising incarnation of the New Woman Politician. On the
face of it, she is just one of the 95 female MPs in Parliament. But ever
since she took over as India’s youngest and first woman education
minister, she has dominated the academic and political narrative. For
the past few months, she has been grabbing headlines and prime time
space for her ministerial performance. Never before has an education
minister occupied the mind space of opinion-makers for so long. Is it
because she is a woman who has successfully stormed a male bastion? Many
adore her. Many more abhor her. But there is hardly anyone of relevance
who can afford to ignore Smriti Irani. The force of her decisions and
assertions, wrong or right, shakes up the most complacent in the
establishment. She has admitted to not holding a degree from any
glamorous university. Yet a large majority of elitist institutions
worldwide are engaged in dissecting and disparaging her personality.
Many of her admirers claim that she is a target not because she belongs
to the Sangh Parivar, but because she articulates her ideology and
beliefs much more convincingly than many of her Ivy League detractors.
She has even been mocked as “Aunty National”—a blatantly sexist
description by any standards—by a smuttily snooty and nefarious
neo-aristocracy. Unfortunately, to the chagrin of many of the exclusive
Indo-Anglian club, a girl from a lower middle class locality of New
Delhi speaks fluent English and delivers her arguments more vigorously
than most of them.
Such vicious personal attacks are reminiscent
of the verbal venom spewed at late Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.
Undoubtedly, she was the author of many controversial decisions. The
reality, however, was that she took on the male-dominated world of
politics and taught many of her seniors lessons in powercraft. When she
challenged the Syndicate’s supremacy, they responded by splitting the
Congress. Yet, by sheer force of personality and conviction, Mrs Gandhi
was able to decimate her opponents within and outside her party in three
years. During her 16-year tenure as Prime Minister, with a brief
interruption in between, she remained the most preferred target of her
political foes until her assassination in October 1984. Today, there are
many fearless women of substance who face resolute resistance from
their male and even female opponents; for example, take three former and
current women chief ministers—Mamata Banerjee, J Jayalalithaa and
Mayawati. None of them have been accorded the political respect normally
given to male chief ministers. All three remain in the crosshairs of
their adversaries. In Delhi, Congress President Sonia Gandhi has always
been on top of the list of her political enemies as the target for the
choicest of adjectives.
Despite facing continuous antagonism, most
women leaders, from Irani to Jayalalithaa, have succeeded in creating
popular acceptability and an independent space for themselves. Sonia has
broken the record for holding the post of the longest-serving Congress
president in the history of the 130-year-old party. It is the example of
their patience and prowess that is inspiring more and more women to
become lawmakers at the Centre and in the states. The current Parliament
has the largest number of women MPs ever. Even in the states, one out
of 10 MLAs is a woman.
Irani is the latest icon in the pantheon of
India’s powerful female leadership, who is not only dictating the
national agenda but is also proving beyond doubt that it is merit that
has raised her to the position she holds than anything else. With more
and more women participating in debates and dialogues, all political
parties are looking for opportunities to replace non-productive male
leaders with effective women warriors. As the HRD minister launched her
high-powered verbal fusillade against her detractors in the House last
week, the Congress couldn’t find an alternative woman leader to counter
her with equal, if not more, voltage. Of the 31 women MPs in the Rajya
Sabha, the Congress has the largest number—nine. The BJP has just four.
But most of the Congress grande dames are too old or ill-equipped to
face the feisty minister. MPs like Wansuk Syiem from Meghalaya, Viplava
Thakur from Himachal Pradesh and Naznin Faruque from Assam have hardly
made any impact in Parliament. Frankly, it was not the Congress but
Mayawati who gave Irani a run for her money as a champion of her core
constituency. Congress leaders Ghulam Nabi Azad and Anand Sharma are
formidable voices, but they are helpless to counter the political
artillery of the acclaimed actor-turned-politician. Other senior leaders
like former Union ministers Mohsina Kidwai and Ambika Soni are
conspicuous by their non-participation in any heated debate. From the
non-BJP parties, only Mayawati and Jaya Bachchan have been able to make
an impression with their interventions.
In the Lok Sabha too, the
Congress lacks powerful female speakers. On the other hand, Prime
Minister Narendra Modi ensured that comparatively younger women
candidates were given tickets during the 2014 Lok Sabha elections. The
average age of women MPs is 47 as against 54 for men. The younger lot
belongs to the BJP. Led by External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj, the
saffron bloc is packed with powerful women orators like Kirron Kher,
Meenakshi Lekhi, Poonam Mahajan and Maneka Gandhi. The Congress, with
its paltry 45 MPs, has hardly any women gladiator except first-timers
like Sushmita Dev from Assam. With the emergence of Irani and her type,
the Congress has to realise that Sonia Gandhi alone is not enough to
move the masses. She needs the assistance of more shaktis in the Indira
mould. Indian politics is stuck at the crossroads of a gender crisis,
from where only women possessing the magnanimity of a mother, the
unconquerable power of Durga, and the multidimensional perspective of a
modern mind will show the right way forward.